“Radiometric dating gives reliable absolute ages for rocks, measured in millions and billions of years.”
§1 The claim, as taught
Isotopic dating of rocks, or the minerals in them, is based on the fact that we know the decay rates of certain unstable isotopes of elements and that these rates have been constant over geological time. It is also based on the premise that when the atoms of an element decay within a mineral or a rock, they stay there and don’t escape to the surrounding rock, water, or air.Earle S. *Physical Geology*, 2nd ed. BCcampus (2019), §8.4 “Isotopic Dating Methods.”
§2 The strongest evidence offered
The physics of decay is not in dispute, and the mainstream case is stronger here than in most places on this site. The question is what links a ratio measured today to an event in the unobserved past.
Steady decay, measured
Decay rates have been measured for a century and are essentially unaffected by temperature, pressure or chemistry under laboratory conditions. The small effects that exist, such as for electron-capture decay, are far too small to matter for dating.Not perfectly constant everywhere
Stripped of all its electrons, rhenium-187 decays about a billion times faster than in a neutral atom. The conditions involved, a fully ionised atom in a storage ring, do not occur in ordinary rock.Concordance and isochrons
Different decay systems in the same rock, and isochron plots across several minerals, often agree. Meteorites give a consistent lead-isotope age of about 4.55 billion years. Agreement between independent methods is the mainstream's strongest argument.Known-age rocks, wrong ages
Lava flows of known historic age have given potassium-argon ages of hundreds of thousands to millions of years, because they inherited argon when they formed. Mainstream geologists documented this first and treat it as a known limitation.The accelerated-decay proposal
A creationist research group (RATE) argued that helium retained in zircons, among other evidence, points to a period of greatly accelerated decay in the past. The group itself acknowledged that such acceleration would release enough heat to melt the crust, a problem it left unsolved.§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one
The measurement and the age are different claims. We grade them separately. Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →
Radioactive decay proceeds at steady, measurable rates under present conditions
ADemonstratedMeasured isotope ratios give the absolute ages of rocks in millions and billions of years
CInference§4 What it would take
To show that the ages are absolute and not model ages, the following would be needed:
- Blind tests on known-age rockDate rocks of independently known age, without being told the expected answer, across the methods used for deep-time ages.
- Initial conditions observedShow, for each method, how the starting isotope ratios are known rather than assumed or fitted.
- All results reportedPublish the full set of dates obtained on a sample, including those rejected as discordant, and the criteria used to reject them.
§5 Another reading of the same data
Radiometric dating rests on excellent physics. Decay rates have been measured for over a century and do not change measurably with heat, pressure or chemistry. Where the methods agree with one another, and they often do, the mainstream reading has real force. This card's grade A for the physics is meant.
An age, though, is a calculation from three inputs: the rate, which is measured, and the starting amount of daughter isotope and the history of the sample since, which are not. A volcanic rock that erupted in 1986 cannot be dated correctly by potassium–argon, because it inherited argon from the magma. That is an admitted limitation, and isochron methods were developed partly to deal with problems like it. But it shows that a precise measurement can give a wrong age when the assumptions do not hold, and in rocks of unknown age the assumptions cannot be checked directly.
Read through a recent-creation lens, two lines of reply are open. One is that much of what is measured reflects the mixing and inheritance of isotopes, not elapsed time. The other, explored by the RATE group, is that decay was faster at some point in the past. Neither is yet a complete account. The second runs into the heat problem, and the RATE authors were candid that they had not solved it. Here the honest position is that the measurements are hard to explain on a short timescale, and that the long-age interpretation depends on assumptions that the measurements themselves cannot confirm.
§6 Reasoning check
The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →
- Possible
Dates that conflict with the expected age of a formation are often set aside as contaminated, and the expected age comes partly from earlier dates and from fossils. Isochrons and concordance tests are a real, partly independent check, which is why this is possible, not clear.
- Possible
“Decay rates are constant” (a measured fact) is used to support “these ages are absolute” (which also needs known initial conditions and closed systems). The first does not deliver the second.
- PossibleIn the evidence: The accelerated-decay proposal
Accelerated decay explains the measured ratios on a short timescale, but it was proposed to save that timescale. Its heat and radiation problems remain open, and an unknown mechanism for removing the heat would be a second rescue.
- Possible
Accelerated nuclear decay was proposed to reconcile the measurements with a young Earth, and its main physical consequence, heat, is unexplained. Its supporters say so openly.
§7 Questions to ponder
- If a lava flow seen to erupt in the 1980s gives an age of hundreds of thousands of years, what does that tell us about lava of unknown age?
- Different methods often agree. How much of that agreement is independent, and how much results from choosing which samples and dates to keep?
- Accelerated decay would release enormous heat. Is a solution to the heat problem a scientific claim, a theological one, or both?
§8 Sources
- Patterson C. “Age of meteorites and the earth.” Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 10:230–237 (1956).B
- Dalrymple GB. The Age of the Earth. Stanford University Press (1991).C
- Emery GT. “Perturbation of nuclear decay rates.” Annual Review of Nuclear Science 22:165–202 (1972).B
- Dalrymple GB. “⁴⁰Ar/³⁶Ar analyses of historic lava flows.” Earth and Planetary Science Letters 6:47–55 (1969).B
- Bosch F et al. “Observation of bound-state β⁻ decay of fully ionized ¹⁸⁷Re: ¹⁸⁷Re–¹⁸⁷Os cosmochronometry.” Physical Review Letters 77:5190–5193 (1996).B
- Austin SA. “Excess argon within mineral concentrates from the new dacite lava dome at Mount St Helens volcano.” CEN Technical Journal 10(3):335–343 (1996).C
- Vardiman L, Snelling AA, Chaffin EF (eds.). Radioisotopes and the Age of the Earth, vol. II. Institute for Creation Research and Creation Research Society (2005).C
- Humphreys DR, Austin SA, Baumgardner JR, Snelling AA. “Helium diffusion age of 6,000 years supports accelerated nuclear decay.” Creation Research Society Quarterly 41:1–16 (2004).D
Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.