“Humans and chimpanzees are about 98% identical in their DNA, which shows that they share a recent common ancestor.”
§1 The claim, as taught
While the genetic difference between individual humans today is minuscule – about 0.1%, on average – study of the same aspects of the chimpanzee genome indicates a difference of about 1.2%. … No matter how the calculation is done, the big point still holds: humans, chimpanzees, and bonobos are more closely related to one another than either is to gorillas or any other primate.Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History, Human Origins Program. “Genetic Evidence.”
§2 The strongest evidence offered
The numbers are all accurate. They differ because they measure different things.
Two levels
In 1975, before genome sequencing, Mary-Claire King and Allan Wilson estimated from proteins that humans and chimps were about 99% alike, and argued that their large differences in body and behaviour must come mainly from differences in gene regulation.1.23%, where it aligns
The chimpanzee genome project found 1.23% single-letter differences in the DNA that could be aligned with the human genome. Insertions and deletions added several percent more, and some regions could not be aligned at all.Counting the gaps
When insertions and deletions are counted, the difference rises to about 5%, as Roy Britten reported in 2002. Gene copy number also differs: in one analysis, humans and chimps differed by about 6% in the gene families they carry.Higher-quality genomes
Better-assembled ape genomes have found more structural differences, including duplications, inversions and regions unique to each species, than the first drafts showed.§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one
The measurement and its interpretation need separate grades. Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →
Where human and chimp DNA can be aligned, it differs by about 1.2% in single letters
ADemonstratedThis similarity shows that humans and chimps share a recent common ancestor
CInference§4 What it would take
To make similarity decisive evidence for shared ancestry, the following would be needed:
- A prediction design cannot makeSpecify a pattern of similarity that common ancestry predicts and common design does not, and show it holds.
- The whole genome, not the aligned partReport the total difference, including insertions, deletions, duplications and unalignable sequence, alongside the aligned figure.
§5 Another reading of the same data
The 98% figure is not wrong. It is accurate for the part of the genome that can be lined up letter by letter, and on that measure humans and chimpanzees are very similar indeed. The problem is with what is left out and with what is inferred.
What is left out is everything that does not align: insertions, deletions, duplicated genes and rearranged regions. Counting them brings the difference to several percent, and better genomes keep finding more. Even so, the difference that matters most may not be a percentage at all. King and Wilson saw in 1975 that the large differences between humans and chimps must lie largely in how genes are regulated, which a percentage of letters cannot capture.
What is inferred is ancestry. Similarity is what common descent predicts, and it is also what a designer of two similar bodies, with similar organs and similar biochemistry, would be expected to produce. Read through a design lens, humans share a great deal with apes because we share a common bodily plan, and the differences that make us human, in language, abstract thought and moral sense, are exactly the kind that a letter count does not measure.
§6 Reasoning check
The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →
- Possible
The headline figure comes from the aligned regions. It is accurate, but presenting it as the total difference leaves out the insertions, deletions and duplications that also differ.
- Clear case
Common ancestry predicts similarity; humans and chimps are similar; so they share an ancestor. Similar bodies built by a common designer would also be expected to share much of their DNA. Similarity alone does not choose between them.
- Possible
Critics sometimes quote the lowest available figure as if it overturned the comparison. Even counted strictly, humans and chimps are more alike genetically than either is to other apes, and that ordering is what the mainstream argument relies on.
§7 Questions to ponder
- If humans and chimps are 98% identical, where does the other 2% (or more) do its work?
- Would 90% similarity have counted against common ancestry? Would 99.9%?
- Does similar DNA in two similar bodies point more to common descent, or to a common designer, or to neither?
§8 Sources
- King MC, Wilson AC. “Evolution at two levels in humans and chimpanzees.” Science 188:107–116 (1975).B
- Britten RJ. “Divergence between samples of chimpanzee and human DNA sequences is 5%, counting indels.” PNAS 99:13633–13635 (2002).B
- Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium. “Initial sequence of the chimpanzee genome and comparison with the human genome.” Nature 437:69–87 (2005).A
- Cohen J. “Relative differences: the myth of 1%.” Science 316:1836 (2007).C
- Kronenberg ZN et al. “High-resolution comparative analysis of great ape genomes.” Science 360:eaar6343 (2018).B
- Demuth JP, De Bie T, Stajich JE, Cristianini N, Hahn MW. “The evolution of mammalian gene families.” PLoS ONE 1:e85 (2006).B
- Gauger A, Axe D, Luskin C. Science and Human Origins. Discovery Institute Press (2012).C
Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.