Claim № 9.04  · Pillar 9 · Case file

“The hominin fossils document a line of descent from an ape-like ancestor to modern humans.”

Disciplines: Paleoanthropology · Comparative anatomy
Status: draft · pending expert review
UnderExaminationTwo claims · two grades

§1 The claim, as taught

Human evolution is the lengthy process of change by which people originated from apelike ancestors. Scientific evidence shows that the physical and behavioral traits shared by all people originated from apelike ancestors and evolved over a period of approximately six million years.Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History, Human Origins Program. “Introduction to Human Evolution.”

§2 The strongest evidence offered

The fossils are real, and their discovery is one of the great achievements of field science. The questions are how they are arranged, and what the arrangement shows.

Observed

Lucy and the footprints

The partial skeleton known as Lucy, about 3.2 million years old on the standard dating, combines an ape-sized brain and long arms with a pelvis and knee adapted to walking upright. Footprints at Laetoli, dated older still, show an upright, human-like gait.
Johanson & White, Science 203 (1979); Leakey & Hay, Nature 278 (1979).
Observed

Turkana Boy

A nearly complete skeleton of a young Homo erectus, dated to about 1.5 million years, has body proportions much like a modern human's, though its brain was smaller.
Brown et al., Nature 316 (1985)
Observed

Mosaic forms

Several fossils mix features in unexpected ways. Australopithecus sediba has a small brain with some Homo-like features in the hand and pelvis. Homo naledi has a brain the size of an australopith's, yet is dated to only 236,000–335,000 years ago, long after larger-brained Homo appear.
Berger et al., Science 328 (2010); Berger et al., eLife 4 (2015); Dirks et al., eLife 6 (2017).
Inferred

A bush, not a line

Leading paleoanthropologists describe the hominin record as a branching bush, not a ladder. Wood and Collard proposed moving Homo habilis and H. rudolfensis out of Homo altogether. Wood and Harrison warned that similar features can arise independently, which makes ancestors hard to identify.
Wood & Collard, Science 284 (1999); Wood & Harrison, Nature 470 (2011).
Observed

Two kinds of body

In the inner ear, which governs balance, australopiths resemble apes and Homo erectus resembles modern humans. The limb proportions of one Homo habilis specimen appear more ape-like than Lucy's.
Spoor, Wood & Zonneveld, Nature 369 (1994); Hartwig-Scherer & Martin, Journal of Human Evolution 21 (1991).
Inferred

Where creationists draw the line

Creationists agree that Neanderthals and Homo erectus were fully human, and that most australopiths were not. They disagree about the fossils in between: Todd Wood's analysis placed H. habilis, H. rudolfensis and A. sediba with humans, and other creationists dissented. Phil Senter argued that this disagreement is what genuine intermediates would produce.
Wood, Answers Research Journal 3 (2010); Senter, American Biology Teacher 72 (2010).

§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one

That the fossils exist, and combine features, is one claim. That they form a line of descent is another. Graded separately: Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →

Hominin fossils exist that combine ape-like and human-like features, such as upright walking with an ape-sized brain

ADemonstrated
Observation
///
Skeletons, skulls and footprints, observed and measured directly.
Hypothesis
///
A clear claim about anatomy.
Prediction
//
Mixed forms were expected in Africa, and were found there.
Experiment
//
Anatomical measurement and comparison, not experiment.
Replication
///
Many specimens, studied by many teams.
Falsifiability
///
The anatomy can be checked against the specimens and casts.
Method score 16/18

The fossils document a line of descent from an ape-like ancestor to modern humans

CInference
Observation
/
Descent is inferred; no fossil can show whether it left descendants.
Hypothesis
//
A clear hypothesis, though the proposed tree changes often.
Prediction
//
Mosaic forms are predicted by descent, and found.
Experiment
/
Ages overlap and sometimes run out of order (*H. naledi*); the anatomy divides into two groups at key points.
Replication
/
Specialists disagree about which species are ancestors and which are side branches.
Falsifiability
//
Fully modern humans found deep in the sequence would count against it; the arrangement of the rest is flexible.
Method score 9/18
ADemonstratedBStrongly supportedCInferenceDExtrapolationEAssumption

§4 What it would take

To show a line of descent, and not only a collection of fossils, the following would be needed:

  • A test for ancestryCriteria that identify a fossil as an ancestor, not a side branch, applied before the tree is drawn.
  • A consistent sequenceAn account of the overlapping dates and out-of-order forms, such as a small-brained Homo naledi living long after Homo erectus, that does not simply add another branch.
  • A bridge across the divideFossils that join the australopith body plan to the Homo erectus body plan, in the features where the two groups differ most, such as the inner ear and limb proportions.

§5 Another reading of the same data

The hominin fossils are the evidence most people picture when they think of human evolution, and they deserve respect. They were found by years of hard field work, often in difficult places, and some are extraordinary: a skeleton forty per cent complete, footprints left in volcanic ash, a cave chamber holding the bones of more than a dozen individuals. Creationists who dismiss them as frauds or as “just apes and just humans” without looking at the anatomy do their case no favours.

What the fossils show is a set of creatures, some clearly ape-like, some clearly human, and some hard to place. The specialists' own picture is not the line of the familiar drawing but a bush, with forms that overlap in time and sometimes appear out of the expected order. At several points the anatomy falls into two groups: australopiths, which walked upright but kept ape-like ears, limbs and brains, and Homo erectus and later humans, whose bodies were much like ours. The fossils in between are few, fragmentary and disputed, by evolutionary biologists and creationists alike.

Read through a creation lens, the record fits a world that held extinct apes of kinds unlike any alive today, some of which walked upright, alongside humans of varied build descended from the first pair. That reading has its own work to do. It has to say where the boundary lies, and why, before the next fossil is found, and Todd Wood's analyses are an honest attempt at that. The fossils show that the human story is less simple than either side has sometimes claimed.

§6 Reasoning check

The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →

In the claim as taught
  • Possible

    The familiar “march” image, and many textbook diagrams, set a few fossils in a line. Specialists describe a bush with overlapping and out-of-order forms, which a line hides.

  • Possible

    Descent predicts fossils with mixed features. So does a created world containing extinct apes of several kinds and humans of varied build. Finding mixed features does not by itself choose between them.

In the other reading
  • Possible

    If each disputed fossil can be assigned to “ape” or “human” after it is found, the creation reading risks the same flexibility it criticises. It needs criteria for the boundary stated in advance, and Wood's baraminology is an attempt at that.

  • Possible

    Saying that Lucy was “just a chimpanzee” misstates the evidence. Her pelvis and knee were adapted to upright walking. A fair creation reading treats her as an extinct ape unlike any living one.

§7 Questions to ponder

  • If the hominin record is a bush, which fossils are our ancestors? How would we know?
  • Creationists disagree about where some fossils belong. Does that show they are intermediates, or that the fossils are hard to classify on any view?
  • What would a created group of extinct apes, and a created human kind with great early variety, predict about the fossil record?

§8 Sources

Supporting the mainstream claim
  1. Johanson DC, White TD. “A systematic assessment of early African hominids.” Science 203:321–330 (1979).B
  2. Leakey MD, Hay RL. “Pliocene footprints in the Laetolil Beds at Laetoli, northern Tanzania.” Nature 278:317–323 (1979).B
  3. Brown F, Harris J, Leakey R, Walker A. “Early Homo erectus skeleton from west Lake Turkana, Kenya.” Nature 316:788–792 (1985).B
  4. Berger LR et al. “Australopithecus sediba: a new species of Homo-like australopith from South Africa.” Science 328:195–204 (2010).B
  5. Berger LR et al. “Homo naledi, a new species of the genus Homo from the Dinaledi Chamber, South Africa.” eLife 4:e09560 (2015).B
  6. Dirks PHGM et al. “The age of Homo naledi and associated sediments in the Rising Star Cave, South Africa.” eLife 6:e24231 (2017).B
  7. Lordkipanidze D et al. “A complete skull from Dmanisi, Georgia, and the evolutionary biology of early Homo.” Science 342:326–331 (2013).B
  8. Wood B, Collard M. “The human genus.” Science 284:65–71 (1999).B
  9. Wood B, Harrison T. “The evolutionary context of the first hominins.” Nature 470:347–352 (2011).B
  10. Spoor F, Wood B, Zonneveld F. “Implications of early hominid labyrinthine morphology for evolution of human bipedal locomotion.” Nature 369:645–648 (1994).B
  11. Hartwig-Scherer S, Martin RD. “Was ‘Lucy’ more human than her ‘child’? Observations on early hominid postcranial skeletons.” Journal of Human Evolution 21:439–449 (1991).B
  12. Senter P. “Were australopithecines ape–human intermediates or just apes? A test of both hypotheses using the ‘Lucy’ skeleton.” American Biology Teacher 72:70–76 (2010).C
Critical & alternative perspectives
  1. Wood TC. “Baraminological analysis places Homo habilis, Homo rudolfensis, and Australopithecus sediba in the human holobaramin.” Answers Research Journal 3:71–90 (2010).C
  2. Gauger A, Axe D, Luskin C. Science and Human Origins. Discovery Institute Press (2012).C
  3. Lubenow ML. Bones of Contention: A Creationist Assessment of Human Fossils, rev. ed. Baker (2004).C

Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.

§9 Your notes