“Observed speciation shows that macroevolution happens: the same process, given time, produces all the major groups.”
§1 The claim, as taught
Just as in microevolution, basic evolutionary mechanisms like mutation, migration, genetic drift, and natural selection are at work and can help explain many large-scale patterns in the history of life. The basic evolutionary mechanisms — mutation, migration, genetic drift, and natural selection — can produce major evolutionary change if given enough time.University of California Museum of Paleontology. *Understanding Evolution*, “Evolution 101.”
§2 The strongest evidence offered
Speciation is well documented. Note what changes in each case: the ability or willingness to interbreed.
New plant species, in decades
Two new species of goatsbeard (Tragopogon) arose in the American northwest in the early twentieth century, when introduced species hybridised and doubled their chromosomes. The new species cannot breed with their parents.A fly that changed hosts
Apple maggot flies began laying eggs on apples, introduced to North America, in the 1800s. Apple-infesting and hawthorn-infesting flies are now genetically distinct and partly isolated by timing.Isolation in the lab
Fruit-fly populations raised on different foods for a few dozen generations came to prefer mating within their own line. Reviews of forty years of such experiments found that reproductive isolation arises readily.More than micro, repeated
Douglas Erwin argued that the origin of major groups involves processes, such as the origin of developmental novelty, that do not reduce to the population changes seen in speciation. Reznick and Ricklefs reviewed how far the link between the two has been demonstrated, and called it a research programme.§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one
The observation and the extrapolation need separate grades. Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →
New species arise by reproductive isolation
ADemonstratedSpeciation, repeated, produces new body plans and the major groups
DExtrapolation§4 What it would take
To show that speciation explains macroevolution, the following would be needed:
- Novelty, not just isolationA case in which speciation is accompanied by a new structure or organ, not only by a change in mating, timing or chromosome number.
- A path between groupsA step-by-step, testable account of how repeated speciation produced one major group from another, such as the origin of insects or of mammals.
§5 Another reading of the same data
The young-earth view is often misrepresented here. Creation scientists do not deny that new species form. Most argue that speciation was rapid after the Flood, as the animals on the Ark diversified to fill the world. The observed cases, plants formed by chromosome doubling, flies switching hosts, lab populations that stop interbreeding, are welcome evidence of how fast it can happen.
What those cases show, though, is reproductive isolation: a change in who breeds with whom. In none of them did a new organ, tissue type or body plan appear. The new goatsbeards are goatsbeards; the apple flies are flies. Calling this “macroevolution” is a definition. It is true that it is evolution above the species level, but it is not the kind of change at issue when we ask where insects or mammals came from.
Read through a creation lens, living things were made as distinct kinds with built-in capacity to diversify, and speciation is part of that capacity. That reading predicts that species within a kind will often still hybridise, which is common in ducks, cats, dogs and finches, and that hybridisation will stop at deeper boundaries. Baraminology attempts to map those boundaries with explicit criteria. It is a young field, and its boundaries are still contested even among its practitioners.
§6 Reasoning check
The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →
- Clear case
“Speciation” means a population becoming reproductively isolated. The argument then treats it as a sample of “macroevolution” in the sense of the origin of new body plans, which is a different thing.
- Clear case
From populations splitting into similar species to the origin of the phyla, without evidence that the first process can produce the novelty the second requires.
- Possible
Once creationists accept speciation, the limit moves to “kinds.” If the kind is defined only after the fact, wherever hybridisation stops, the boundary can absorb any observation. Baraminology tries to give it independent criteria.
§7 Questions to ponder
- In each observed case, what was new in the new species?
- Creationists accept rapid speciation within created kinds. Does observed speciation tell us anything about where the kinds came from?
- If a doubling of chromosomes creates a new plant species overnight, is “species” the right unit for measuring how much evolution has happened?
§8 Sources
- Ownbey M. “Natural hybridization and amphiploidy in the genus Tragopogon.” American Journal of Botany 37:487–499 (1950).B
- Feder JL, Chilcote CA, Bush GL. “Genetic differentiation between sympatric host races of the apple maggot fly Rhagoletis pomonella.” Nature 336:61–64 (1988).B
- Dodd DMB. “Reproductive isolation as a consequence of adaptive divergence in Drosophila pseudoobscura.” Evolution 43:1308–1311 (1989).B
- Rice WR, Hostert EE. “Laboratory experiments on speciation: what have we learned in 40 years?” Evolution 47:1637–1653 (1993).B
- Coyne JA, Orr HA. Speciation. Sinauer (2004).C
- Gould SJ. “Is a new and general theory of evolution emerging?” Paleobiology 6:119–130 (1980).C
- Erwin DH. “Macroevolution is more than repeated rounds of microevolution.” Evolution & Development 2:78–84 (2000).C
- Reznick DN, Ricklefs RE. “Darwin's bridge between microevolution and macroevolution.” Nature 457:837–842 (2009).C
- Wood TC, Wise KP, Sanders R, Doran N. “A refined baramin concept.” Occasional Papers of the Baraminology Study Group 3:1–14 (2003).C
Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.