Claim № 5.02  · Pillar 5 · Case file

“The peppered moth demonstrates natural selection: dark moths increased when pollution darkened the trees, because birds ate the pale ones.”

Disciplines: Ecology · Genetics
Status: reviewed 2026-11-15
UnderExaminationTwo claims · two grades

§1 The claim, as taught

Perhaps one of the best known is the color change observed in peppered moths in England during the 19th century. … When soot from coal factories began to cover the bark of the trees, the black moths became better camouflaged and the white moths were now more visible. Consequently, the black moths were the ones to survive to reproduce, while the white ones were eaten.Hasty J, Lewis DG, Snipes MM. Introduction to Anthropology. OpenStax (2022), §4.4 “Evolution in Action: Past and Present.”

§2 The strongest evidence offered

The peppered moth story was criticised for decades and then largely confirmed. Both halves belong in the account.

Observed

Rise and fall

The dark (carbonaria) form went from unknown before about 1848 to over 90% of moths around Manchester by the late 1800s. After clean-air laws, it declined again in Britain, and in parallel in the United States.
Grant, Owen & Clarke, Journal of Heredity 87 (1996)
Observed

Kettlewell's experiments

In the 1950s Bernard Kettlewell released marked moths in polluted and clean woods and recaptured a higher proportion of the better-camouflaged form in each. He also filmed birds taking moths from tree trunks.
Kettlewell, Heredity 9 (1955) and 10 (1956)
Observed

The staged photographs

Textbook photographs of moths resting on trunks were often posed, using dead or chilled moths. Peppered moths mostly rest higher in the canopy, under branches.
Majerus, Melanism: Evolution in Action (1998); Hooper, Of Moths and Men (2002).
Observed

The last experiment

Michael Majerus released nearly 5,000 moths over seven years, at natural densities and resting sites, and watched birds eat them. The pale form survived better in unpolluted Cambridge, enough to explain the decline of the dark form.
Cook, Grant, Saccheri & Mallet, Biology Letters 8 (2012)
Observed

The mutation itself

The dark form is caused by a transposable element, a piece of mobile DNA, inserted into an intron of the cortex gene. It probably arose once, around 1819, and spread from there.
Van't Hof et al., Nature 534 (2016)

§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one

The example demonstrates something. The question is what. Graded separately: Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →

Bird predation shifted the frequency of dark and pale moths as the environment changed

BStrongly supported
Observation
///
The frequency changes are documented over 150 years, on two continents.
Hypothesis
///
A specific mechanism: visual predation on resting moths.
Prediction
//
The decline after clean-air laws was predicted and observed.
Experiment
//
Field experiments, with flaws in the early ones corrected in later ones.
Replication
//
Confirmed by Majerus, but the decisive experiment has one main author.
Falsifiability
///
Other causes (migration, differential fitness) were considered and tested.
Method score 15/18

The peppered moth shows how natural selection creates new kinds of organisms

EAssumption
Observation
—
Both colour forms are the same species; nothing new in kind appeared.
Hypothesis
/
The claim is rarely stated, but implied by the example's use.
Prediction
—
The example predicts a change in proportions, not a new structure.
Experiment
—
No experiment addresses it.
Replication
/
The colour change reversed when the environment did.
Falsifiability
/
Any shift in proportions is taken to illustrate the larger claim.
Method score 3/18
ADemonstratedBStrongly supportedCInferenceDExtrapolationEAssumption

§4 What it would take

To turn the peppered moth from an illustration of selection into evidence for the theory's larger claim, it would need to show:

  • Beyond a colour switchA change that adds a new structure or function, not a shift between two forms of one species.
  • A change that does not reverseDirectional change that persists when the environment that drove it goes back.

§5 Another reading of the same data

The peppered moth has had a strange career. For decades it was the textbook proof of natural selection. Then critics showed that the photographs were staged and that the early experiments had flaws, and some concluded that the story was false. Then Michael Majerus ran a careful, seven-year experiment, and the central claim held: birds really did eat the more visible moths, and that really did drive the change. The story was mostly right.

What it was right about is modest. There were two colour forms of one species. Their proportions changed with the environment and changed back when it did. The dark form came from a single mutation, a piece of mobile DNA landing in a gene that affects wing colour. That is a fine illustration of selection acting on an existing variant. It is not evidence that selection builds wings, scales or moths.

Read through a design lens, the moth is an organism with built-in variability that let some of its members survive a sudden human-made change in their surroundings. That variability, and the mobile DNA that can switch genes, may itself be part of how organisms were made to adapt. The lesson for students is to keep two questions apart: did selection happen? (yes) and what did it make? (a different ratio of dark to pale moths).

§6 Reasoning check

The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →

In the claim as taught
  • Possible

    Evolution is used both for a change in the proportion of two colour forms and for the origin of moths. The example demonstrates the first.

  • Possible

    Usually the textbook only says the moths show selection, which is fair. The extrapolation comes from presenting it as a demonstration of evolution in general.

  • Possible
    In the evidence: Kettlewell's experiments

    Critics noted that moths were released in daylight onto trunks at high densities, conditions that may have exaggerated predation. The objections concern design, not honesty, and later work addressed most of them.

In the other reading
  • Possible

    Some critics wrote as if the staged photographs and Kettlewell's flaws meant that selection had not occurred. Majerus showed that it had. The fair criticism is about scope, not about whether the moths were eaten.

§7 Questions to ponder

  • Was the peppered moth story wrong, or was it right about something smaller than what it was used to show?
  • Does a gene switched on or off by a piece of mobile DNA count as new information? See Pillar 4.
  • Why did staged photographs matter so much to critics, if the conclusion turned out to be largely right?

§8 Sources

Supporting the mainstream claim
  1. Kettlewell HBD. “Selection experiments on industrial melanism in the Lepidoptera.” Heredity 9:323–342 (1955).B
  2. Grant BS, Owen DF, Clarke CA. “Parallel rise and fall of melanic peppered moths in America and Britain.” Journal of Heredity 87:351–357 (1996).B
  3. Majerus MEN. Melanism: Evolution in Action. Oxford University Press (1998).C
  4. Coyne JA. “Not black and white.” Nature 396:35–36 (1998).C
  5. Cook LM, Grant BS, Saccheri IJ, Mallet J. “Selective bird predation on the peppered moth: the last experiment of Michael Majerus.” Biology Letters 8:609–612 (2012).B
  6. Van't Hof AE et al. “The industrial melanism mutation in British peppered moths is a transposable element.” Nature 534:102–105 (2016).A
Critical & alternative perspectives
  1. Hooper J. Of Moths and Men: An Evolutionary Tale. W. W. Norton (2002).C
  2. Wells J. Icons of Evolution. Regnery (2000), ch. 7.C

Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.

§9 Your notes