“Before DNA and proteins, life passed through an RNA world, in which RNA molecules both stored information and catalysed their own copying.”
§1 The claim, as taught
Some origin of life researchers believe that prebiotic chemistry was based on molecules that could both store information and do the chemical work of the cell. It has been suggested that RNA (ribonucleic acid), a molecule that aids in the flow of genetic information from DNA to proteins, might have served such a purpose. The idea of an early “RNA world” has become increasingly accepted, but a great deal remains to be understood about the origin of life.Fraknoi A, Morrison D, Wolff SC. Astronomy 2e. OpenStax (2022), §30.2 “Astrobiology.”
§2 The strongest evidence offered
The RNA world is the leading hypothesis for good reasons. Here is what supports it, and what the field itself says is missing.
RNA can be an enzyme
In the early 1980s, Thomas Cech and Sidney Altman discovered RNA molecules that catalyse chemical reactions (ribozymes). The core of the ribosome, which joins amino acids into proteins, turned out to be RNA.The RNA world proposed
Walter Gilbert named the RNA world in 1986: a stage in which RNA molecules catalysed their own replication before proteins and DNA took over.Making nucleotides
John Sutherland's group made two of RNA's four nucleotides from simple starting chemicals by a route that bypasses free ribose, which had been a major obstacle. The route needs a sequence of steps with different conditions and reagents added in order.Ribozymes that copy
Gerald Joyce's lab evolved a pair of ribozymes that copy each other indefinitely, given supplies of pre-made RNA pieces. Philipp Holliger's lab evolved a ribozyme that can copy RNA strands up to about 200 letters long, though not itself.The problems, stated by the field
RNA's sugar, ribose, is unstable and hard to make selectively; activated nucleotides do not readily join into long chains; and the best replicating ribozymes were found by directed evolution from large designed libraries, not from prebiotic chemistry. Robertson and Joyce call the RNA world a hypothesis with substantial gaps.§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one
RNA's abilities are one claim; the RNA world as a stage of history is another. Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →
RNA can store information and catalyse chemical reactions, including RNA copying
ADemonstratedLife began in an RNA world that arose from prebiotic chemistry
DExtrapolation§4 What it would take
To establish an RNA world, the following would be needed:
- A replicator from scratchObtain a self-replicating RNA from random sequences formed under prebiotic conditions, not selected from designed libraries.
- One pot, no chemistMake all four nucleotides, and join them into long chains, under a single set of geochemically plausible conditions without purification between steps.
- A path onwardShow how an RNA replicator could come to direct protein synthesis and the genetic code.
§5 Another reading of the same data
The discovery of ribozymes was a real surprise and a real insight. It solved a chicken-and-egg puzzle: DNA needs proteins to be copied, and proteins need DNA to be made, but RNA can in principle do both jobs. The ribosome, the cell's protein factory, has RNA at its catalytic heart. It is easy to see why the RNA world became the leading hypothesis.
Forty years on, the hypothesis has partial successes and a central gap. Chemists have made some nucleotides, and have evolved ribozymes that copy RNA. But the nucleotide syntheses require a series of carefully staged steps, and the ribozymes were found by directed evolution: by researchers building enormous libraries of sequences, selecting the best performers over many rounds and refining them. That is a demonstration of what intelligent selection can achieve with RNA. It is not yet a demonstration of what happened without it.
Read through a design lens, the very features that make the RNA world attractive, a molecule that can hold information and act on it, are features of an elegant, integrated system in which information and machinery depend on each other. The experiments that come closest to an RNA world are experiments in design: a chemist chooses the reagents, sets the order of steps and selects the winners. That is not an argument from what we do not know. It is an observation about what, so far, has been required.
§6 Reasoning check
The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →
- Clear case
From ribozymes that exist today, or that were selected in the lab, to an ancient RNA world that arose by itself.
- Possible
The RNA world is sometimes defended on the grounds that no better natural hypothesis exists. That is a reason to keep researching, not evidence that it happened.
- PossibleIn the evidence: Making nucleotides
The chemistry is real and elegant, but each step uses purified reagents under conditions the chemist sets. Whether a natural setting could supply the same sequence is a further claim.
- Possible
Saying “no natural route could ever produce a replicator” goes beyond the evidence. What the evidence shows is that none has been found, and that the experiments that come closest depend on intelligent choices.
§7 Questions to ponder
- If the best replicating ribozymes came from designed libraries and selection by experimenters, what do they show about undirected chemistry?
- Why might researchers keep the RNA world as their working hypothesis even while listing its gaps?
- Is an intelligent chemist's skill in these experiments a confound, or a clue?
§8 Sources
- Kruger K et al. “Self-splicing RNA: autoexcision and autocyclization of the ribosomal RNA intervening sequence of Tetrahymena.” Cell 31:147–157 (1982).A
- Guerrier-Takada C, Gardiner K, Marsh T, Pace N, Altman S. “The RNA moiety of ribonuclease P is the catalytic subunit of the enzyme.” Cell 35:849–857 (1983).A
- Gilbert W. “Origin of life: the RNA world.” Nature 319:618 (1986).C
- Nissen P, Hansen J, Ban N, Moore PB, Steitz TA. “The structural basis of ribosome activity in peptide bond synthesis.” Science 289:920–930 (2000).A
- Powner MW, Gerland B, Sutherland JD. “Synthesis of activated pyrimidine ribonucleotides in prebiotically plausible conditions.” Nature 459:239–242 (2009).B
- Lincoln TA, Joyce GF. “Self-sustained replication of an RNA enzyme.” Science 323:1229–1232 (2009).B
- Wochner A, Attwater J, Coulson A, Holliger P. “Ribozyme-catalyzed transcription of an active ribozyme.” Science 332:209–212 (2011).B
- Attwater J, Raguram A, Morgunov AS, Gianni E, Holliger P. “Ribozyme-catalysed RNA synthesis using triplet building blocks.” eLife 7:e35255 (2018).B
- Robertson MP, Joyce GF. “The origins of the RNA world.” Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology 4:a003608 (2012).C
- Shapiro R. “The improbability of prebiotic nucleic acid synthesis.” Origins of Life 14:565–570 (1984).C
- Meyer SC. Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design. HarperOne (2009), chs. 14–15.C
- Tour JM. “Animadversions of a synthetic chemist.” Inference: International Review of Science 2(2) (2016).C
Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.