“Design inferences are unscientific by definition, because science can only consider natural causes.”
§1 The claim, as taught
After a searching review of the record and applicable caselaw, we find that while ID arguments may be true, a proposition on which the Court takes no position, ID is not science. We find that ID fails on three different levels, any one of which is sufficient to preclude a determination that ID is science. They are: (1) ID violates the centuries-old ground rules of science by invoking and permitting supernatural causation …Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District, 400 F. Supp. 2d 707 (M.D. Pa. 2005), part 4, “Whether ID is Science.” A court ruling, not a textbook, but the statement most often cited for this claim.
§2 The strongest evidence offered
This card concerns the rules of science, not the evidence for design. Whether design is true is a separate question from whether it may be considered.
Design detected every day
Archaeologists distinguish tools from naturally broken stones; forensic scientists distinguish murder from accident; cryptographers distinguish messages from noise; SETI researchers look for signals that only an intelligence would send. Each infers design from features of the evidence.No agreed line
The philosopher Larry Laudan argued in 1983 that every proposed criterion for separating science from non-science had failed, and that the demarcation question should be replaced by asking whether a claim is well supported by evidence.The Dover ruling
In Kitzmiller v. Dover (2005), Judge John E. Jones III ruled that intelligent design is not science, partly because it invokes supernatural causation, and barred its presentation in a Pennsylvania school district's science classes.“A Divine Foot in the door”
Richard Lewontin wrote that scientists take the side of science against common sense because of a prior commitment to materialism, which is absolute: “we cannot allow a Divine Foot in the door.”Philosophers on both sides
Thomas Nagel, an atheist, argued that intelligent design is not excluded from science by definition, and that the case against it must be made on the evidence. Boudry and colleagues argued that methodological naturalism is not a rule laid down in advance but a summary of what has worked.§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one
A working method and a definition are different things. Graded separately: Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →
Seeking natural causes is a fruitful working rule in experimental science
BStrongly supportedDesign inferences are unscientific by definition
EAssumption§4 What it would take
To show that design is unscientific in a way that does not beg the question, the following would be needed:
- A criterion that worksA demarcation criterion that excludes design in biology but does not exclude design inferences in archaeology, forensics or SETI.
- Engage the evidenceShow, on the evidence, that natural causes are adequate for the features at issue, rather than ruling the alternative out of bounds.
§5 Another reading of the same data
Methodological naturalism, the rule that science seeks natural causes, has served science well. When a disease breaks out, looking for a pathogen works better than looking for a curse. No one on this site would want to abandon that habit in the laboratory. The question is what happens when the same rule is applied to the origin of life and of its major forms, and is stated not as a habit but as a definition.
As a definition it settles the question before the evidence is heard. If science may only consider natural causes, then however strong the evidence for design, the scientific answer can only be “a natural cause we have not yet found.” Lewontin, to his credit, said so openly. Laudan, no friend of creationism, argued that labels such as “unscientific” often do only emotive work, and that the real question is whether a claim is well supported. And design inferences are routine in other sciences: archaeology, forensics and SETI all distinguish intelligent causes from natural ones by their effects.
Read through a design lens, the right rule is simpler: follow the evidence, and name the cause that best explains it. Sometimes that will be a natural process; sometimes, as with a stone tool or a coded signal, an intelligence. Design advocates also have a burden. They need to say how design is detected, as Dembski and Meyer try to, and to accept that if natural causes prove adequate, the inference fails. That is a contest of evidence, which is what the rest of this site is for.
§6 Reasoning check
The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →
- Clear case
If science is defined as the search for natural causes, then “life has a natural cause” is the only scientific answer, before any evidence is weighed. The conclusion is built into the definition.
- Possible
Design arguments are sometimes dismissed because of the religious beliefs or motives of those who make them. The Dover ruling relied partly on the history of the movement. Arguments stand or fall on their merits.
- Possible
Design advocates sometimes move from “design can be detected” (archaeology) to “the designer of life can be identified.” The first is a scientific inference. The second, for a Christian, rests on revelation as well, and the site's Theology lens treats it separately.
§7 Questions to ponder
- If SETI found a signal that only an intelligence could send, would detecting it be science?
- Is “science may only consider natural causes” a scientific claim? How would it be tested?
- Should a court decide what counts as science?
§8 Sources
- Laudan L. “The demise of the demarcation problem.” In Cohen RS, Laudan L (eds.), Physics, Philosophy and Psychoanalysis, pp. 111–127. Reidel (1983).C
- Lewontin R. “Billions and billions of demons.” New York Review of Books 44(1):28–32 (9 January 1997).C
- Pennock RT. Tower of Babel: The Evidence against the New Creationism. MIT Press (1999).C
- Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District, 400 F. Supp. 2d 707 (M.D. Pa. 2005).C
- Boudry M, Blancke S, Braeckman J. “How not to attack intelligent design creationism: philosophical misconceptions about methodological naturalism.” Foundations of Science 15:227–244 (2010).C
- Plantinga A. “Methodological naturalism?” Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith 49:143–154 (1997).C
- Nagel T. “Public education and intelligent design.” Philosophy & Public Affairs 36:187–205 (2008).C
- Dembski WA. The Design Inference: Eliminating Chance through Small Probabilities. Cambridge University Press (1998).C
- Meyer SC. Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design. HarperOne (2009).C
Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.