“Genetic drift and natural selection together explain the patterns found across genomes.”
§1 The claim, as taught
Genetic drift is one of the basic mechanisms of evolution. … Genetic drift affects the genetic makeup of the population, but unlike natural selection, through an entirely random process. So although genetic drift is a mechanism of evolution, it doesn’t work to produce adaptations.University of California Museum of Paleontology. *Understanding Evolution*, “Evolution 101.”
§2 The strongest evidence offered
Drift and selection are both real. The question here is about the theory's logic: what pattern would it fail to explain?
Drift is real
Random changes in gene frequency are observed in small lab populations, and their statistics match theory. Drift is a mathematical certainty, not a hypothesis.The neutral theory
Motoo Kimura argued in 1968 that most changes in DNA and protein sequences between species are neutral and fixed by drift, not selection. Part of his argument was Haldane's cost of selection: there were too many changes for selection to have paid for.Fifty years of argument
In 2018 Kern and Hahn argued that the neutral theory has been overturned by evidence of widespread selection in genomes. Jensen and colleagues replied that the neutral theory remains the necessary null model and that the evidence for pervasive selection is overstated.Complexity by drift?
Michael Lynch argues that much of the complexity of eukaryotic genomes, such as introns and mobile elements, arose not by selection but because small populations cannot remove slightly harmful additions. Others see the same features as adaptive.Adaptive stories
Gould and Lewontin warned that biologists too readily explain every feature as an adaptation, telling plausible stories without testing them, and urged that alternatives such as drift and structural constraint be considered.§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one
That drift and selection both act is one claim. That together they explain how genomes came to be is another. Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →
Drift and selection both shape genomes, and their signatures can be measured
BStrongly supportedTogether they explain the origin of genome-wide patterns, including genome complexity
DExtrapolation§4 What it would take
To show that drift and selection explain genome-wide patterns, the following would be needed:
- Predictions in advanceSpecify, before looking, which features of a newly sequenced genome should be adaptive and which neutral, and check.
- A pattern that would not fitState a genome-wide pattern that drift and selection together could not explain.
§5 Another reading of the same data
Drift and selection are both real, and the mathematics of each is solid. The concern on this card is about how they are used together. When a genetic feature appears useful, selection is said to have produced it. When it does not, drift is said to have fixed it. Both explanations are available for every feature, and so the pair can account for any genome.
That is not a fringe complaint. Gould and Lewontin made a version of it in 1979 about adaptive stories. Kimura's neutral theory was itself a revolt against explaining everything by selection. And the field's leading researchers still disagree, after fifty years, about whether most of the genome's history is selection or drift. That disagreement is healthy, but it shows that the combined theory has not yet made the kind of risky prediction that would test it.
Read through a design lens, the question becomes which features of genomes are functional and which are decay. A designed genome subject to centuries of mutation would show both: a core of function, increasingly discovered, and a layer of accumulated damage. That reading makes a testable prediction too: features dismissed as drift-fixed clutter will, in many cases, turn out to have functions. Pillar 8 looks at how that prediction has fared.
§6 Reasoning check
The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →
- Possible
Selection is invoked where a pattern looks adaptive and drift where it does not. Each explanation is testable on its own; the combination, applied after the fact, is hard to test.
- Possible
Gould and Lewontin's criticism of untested adaptive stories was made from within the field and still applies to many genomic claims of selection.
- Possible
That a feature has no known function does not show that it was designed with one. A design reading needs a prediction of which features will turn out functional, as Pillar 8 discusses.
§7 Questions to ponder
- If a feature is adaptive, selection explains it. If not, drift does. What would count against the combination?
- Kimura used Haldane's cost argument to say selection could not have done it all. Has that argument been answered or just set aside?
- Could a designed genome look like it was shaped partly by drift? What would distinguish the two?
§8 Sources
- Buri P. “Gene frequency in small populations of mutant Drosophila.” Evolution 10:367–402 (1956).B
- Kimura M. “Evolutionary rate at the molecular level.” Nature 217:624–626 (1968).B
- Kimura M. The Neutral Theory of Molecular Evolution. Cambridge University Press (1983).C
- Ohta T. “The nearly neutral theory of molecular evolution.” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 23:263–286 (1992).B
- Gould SJ, Lewontin RC. “The spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm: a critique of the adaptationist programme.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B 205:581–598 (1979).C
- Lynch M. “The frailty of adaptive hypotheses for the origins of organismal complexity.” PNAS 104 Suppl. 1:8597–8604 (2007).C
- Lynch M. The Origins of Genome Architecture. Sinauer (2007).C
- Kern AD, Hahn MW. “The neutral theory in light of natural selection.” Molecular Biology and Evolution 35:1366–1371 (2018).C
- Jensen JD et al. “The importance of the Neutral Theory in 1968 and 50 years on: a response to Kern and Hahn 2018.” Evolution 73:111–114 (2019).C
- Sanford JC. Genetic Entropy. FMS Publications (2014), on the limits of selection.C
Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.