“Most of the human genome is non-functional “junk,” the leftover debris of evolutionary history.”
§1 The claim, as taught
A recent slew of ENCyclopedia Of DNA Elements (ENCODE) Consortium publications, specifically the article signed by all Consortium members, put forward the idea that more than 80% of the human genome is functional. This claim flies in the face of current estimates according to which the fraction of the genome that is evolutionarily conserved through purifying selection is less than 10%.Graur D et al. “On the immortality of television sets: ‘function’ in the human genome according to the evolution-free gospel of ENCODE.” Genome Biology and Evolution 5:578–590 (2013), abstract. The research literature: introductory texts state the junk-DNA view less directly.
§2 The strongest evidence offered
Both sides overstated this one. Here is the evidence as it now stands.
“So much junk”
Susumu Ohno coined the phrase “junk DNA” in 1972. Part of his reasoning was evolutionary: if all of the genome mattered, the mutation load would be too high to bear.Most of it is copied
The ENCODE consortium found that about three-quarters of the human genome is transcribed into RNA in at least one cell type, and assigned some biochemical activity to 80% of it.The critics of ENCODE
Graur and colleagues, and W. Ford Doolittle, argued that activity is not function, and that only DNA under selective constraint should count. ENCODE's leaders later agreed that the 80% figure measured activity, and that function needs further evidence.8.2% under constraint
Comparing mammal genomes, Rands and colleagues estimated that about 8% of the human genome is conserved by selection. On the mainstream reading, the rest is mostly free to mutate and so is mostly non-functional.The case for junk
Palazzo and Gregory point to genome size varying hugely among similar organisms (an onion has about five times as much DNA as a human), to the decaying copies of transposons that make up nearly half our genome, and to mutation-load limits.§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one
How much of the genome is conserved is a measurement. How much of it is functional is an inference from that measurement. Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →
Only a minority of the human genome is under detectable sequence constraint
BStrongly supportedTherefore most of the genome is non-functional junk
CInference§4 What it would take
To settle how much of the genome is functional, the following would be needed:
- Test by deletionDelete or scramble large non-conserved regions in model organisms and measure fitness carefully, over generations and in realistic environments.
- Agree on a definitionAgree a definition of function that does not assume the answer: neither “any activity” nor “only what is conserved.”
- Predict, then checkState in advance which classes of non-coding DNA should prove functional and which should not, and test them.
§5 Another reading of the same data
“Junk DNA” was never only a description. It was also an argument. If most of our genome is useless debris, the debris is evidence of a long, untidy history, and a strong argument against design. That is why the question matters so much to both sides, and why both have sometimes claimed more than the evidence gave.
The junk view took a blow when it turned out that most of the genome is transcribed, and that many non-coding regions regulate genes, structure chromosomes or produce RNAs with roles in development. ENCODE then overreached by counting any biochemical activity as function. The current picture is somewhere in between: a minority of the genome is clearly conserved, a further, unknown share has functions that do not depend on exact sequence, and some is probably decayed copies of mobile elements.
Read through a design lens, the prediction was that more function would be found as research went on, and it has been, though not as much as some advocates claimed. The honest position is that the share of functional DNA is not known, that it is higher than the junk view expected, and that the best way to find out is the one both sides should welcome: careful experiments that remove sequences and measure what is lost.
§6 Reasoning check
The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →
- Possible
For decades, DNA with no known function was treated as DNA with no function. The constraint data now give a positive argument, which keeps this at possible.
- Possible
Ohno's load argument assumed that the human genome was the product of a long evolutionary history in which only a small fraction could be maintained.
- Clear caseIn the evidence: Most of it is copied
ENCODE's 80% counted any reproducible biochemical activity, such as being transcribed or bound by a protein, as “function.” That is not the same as doing something the organism needs, and ENCODE's own leaders later said so.
- PossibleIn the evidence: 8.2% under constraint
Constraint is measured by comparing species assumed to share ancestors over tens of millions of years. Unconserved DNA can still have functions that tolerate sequence change, such as spacing or length-dependent roles.
- Clear case
Design advocates often cited ENCODE's 80% as proof of function. It measured biochemical activity, and treating the two as the same repeats ENCODE's own mistake.
§7 Questions to ponder
- If ENCODE overstated function, did the original “junk” label overstate its absence?
- Does a lack of conservation between species show that a sequence does nothing, or only that its exact letters do not matter?
- Why would genome size vary so much among similar plants and animals on either reading?
§8 Sources
- Ohno S. “So much ‘junk’ DNA in our genome.” Brookhaven Symposia in Biology 23:366–370 (1972).C
- ENCODE Project Consortium. “An integrated encyclopedia of DNA elements in the human genome.” Nature 489:57–74 (2012).B
- Djebali S et al. “Landscape of transcription in human cells.” Nature 489:101–108 (2012).B
- Graur D et al. “On the immortality of television sets: ‘function’ in the human genome according to the evolution-free gospel of ENCODE.” Genome Biology and Evolution 5:578–590 (2013).C
- Doolittle WF. “Is junk DNA bunk? A critique of ENCODE.” PNAS 110:5294–5300 (2013).C
- Kellis M et al. “Defining functional DNA elements in the human genome.” PNAS 111:6131–6138 (2014).B
- Rands CM, Meader S, Ponting CP, Lunter G. “8.2% of the human genome is constrained: variation in rates of turnover across functional element classes in the human lineage.” PLoS Genetics 10:e1004525 (2014).B
- Nóbrega MA, Zhu Y, Plajzer-Frick I, Afzal V, Rubin EM. “Megabase deletions of gene deserts result in viable mice.” Nature 431:988–993 (2004).B
- Palazzo AF, Gregory TR. “The case for junk DNA.” PLoS Genetics 10:e1004351 (2014).C
- Wells J. The Myth of Junk DNA. Discovery Institute Press (2011).C
Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.