Claim № 8.02  · Pillar 8 · Case file

“Shared endogenous retroviruses and pseudogenes, found at the same positions in humans and apes, prove common ancestry.”

Disciplines: Genomics · Virology
Status: reviewed 2026-11-15
UnderExaminationTwo claims · two grades

§1 The claim, as taught

Using the same principles behind DNA fingerprinting, biologists have used transposons, pseudogenes, and endogenous retroviruses to demonstrate that many species are genetically related, such as humans and other primates. … Thus, finding the same pseudogene in the same chromosomal location in two species is strong evidence of common ancestry.Theobald DL. *29+ Evidences for Macroevolution*, TalkOrigins Archive (version 2.89, 2012), Part 4.

§2 The strongest evidence offered

This is a strong argument, and we present it in its strongest form. Two premises carry it: that the features are accidents, and that the accidents are unlikely to repeat.

Observed

Insertions in the same places

Humans and the great apes share thousands of retroviral insertions at matching positions. Johnson and Coffin used them to build a primate family tree, and it matched trees built from other data.
Johnson & Coffin, PNAS 96 (1999)
Observed

The broken vitamin C gene

Humans and other primates cannot make vitamin C, because the gene for its final step (GULO) is disabled. The human copy and other primate copies share some of the same disabling changes.
Nishikimi et al., Journal of Biological Chemistry 269 (1994); Inai et al., J. Nutr. Sci. Vitaminol. 49 (2003).
Observed

Not random

Retroviruses do not insert purely at random. HIV, for example, strongly favours active genes and particular hotspots, which raises the chance that the same site is hit more than once independently.
Schröder et al., Cell 110 (2002)
Observed

Viral genes that work

Some ERV genes have essential roles. Syncytin, the envelope gene of an ERV, is needed to form the human placenta. Other ERV sequences act as switches for immune genes.
Mi et al., Nature 403 (2000); Chuong, Elde & Feschotte, Science 351 (2016).
Observed

Pseudogenes that work, and some that don't

The PTENP1 pseudogene regulates its parent tumour-suppressor gene. A widely cited claim of function for another pseudogene, Makorin1-p1, was later contradicted by a follow-up study.
Poliseno et al., Nature 465 (2010); Hirotsune et al., Nature 423 (2003); Gray et al., PNAS 103 (2006).

§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one

The pattern is one claim; its explanation is another. Graded separately: Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →

Humans and apes share many ERVs and disabled genes at matching positions, in a nested pattern

ADemonstrated
Observation
///
Observed directly in sequenced genomes.
Hypothesis
///
Specific, locus-by-locus claims.
Prediction
///
Predicted nesting largely confirmed.
Experiment
//
Comparative data, checked across many loci.
Replication
///
Replicated across groups and genome assemblies.
Falsifiability
///
Each shared insertion can be checked.
Method score 17/18

These shared features are evidence of common ancestry that design cannot explain

CInference
Observation
//
The features are observed; that they are accidents is inferred.
Hypothesis
///
A clear, specific argument from shared error.
Prediction
//
The nested pattern was predicted, with some exceptions explained by lineage sorting.
Experiment
/
No direct test; integration preferences and functions weaken the key premises.
Replication
//
Widely replicated as a pattern.
Falsifiability
//
Function in the shared elements, or independent insertion at hotspots, would weaken it, and both have been found for some.
Method score 12/18
ADemonstratedBStrongly supportedCInferenceDExtrapolationEAssumption

§4 What it would take

To make the argument decisive, the following would be needed:

  • Show they are accidentsShow, for the shared elements used as evidence, that they have no function, by deleting them and measuring the effect.
  • Show they are unlikely to repeatMeasure, for the specific insertion sites used, how likely independent insertion at the same position is, given known integration preferences.
  • Explain the exceptionsShow that shared elements conflicting with the expected tree are explained by independently tested lineage sorting, not by assumption.

§5 Another reading of the same data

This is one of the best arguments for common descent, and it deserves to be stated at full strength. A retrovirus that inserts its DNA into a germ cell leaves a permanent mark at one point in one genome. If humans and chimpanzees carry the same mark at the same point, the simplest explanation is that it was inserted once, in an ancestor of both. Multiply that by thousands of insertions, arranged in the nested pattern a family tree predicts, and the case looks very strong.

Its force depends on two premises: that the shared elements are accidents with no function, and that insertion at the same place twice is very unlikely. Both have weakened. Retroviruses prefer certain sites, sometimes strongly. And some shared viral sequences turn out to be essential, the placenta gene syncytin being the best-known case, while others act as regulatory switches. A shared functional element is what common design would also produce.

The honest position for a design reading is that not all of the argument has been answered. The shared disabling changes in the vitamin C gene, and the sheer number of shared, apparently inactive insertions, remain a real challenge. One response is that some ERV-like sequences were part of the original design, with roles in regulation, and that the shared mutations reflect damage at mutational hotspots. That is a hypothesis, not yet a demonstrated one, and the card leaves it there.

§6 Reasoning check

The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →

In the claim as taught
  • Possible

    The argument's force rests on an unstated premise: a designer would not place the same non-functional sequences in different species. That may be a fair expectation, but it is a claim about God, not about DNA.

  • Possible

    Shared elements are counted as accidents because no function was known. Function has since been found in some of them.

In the other reading
  • Possible

    Design advocates cite syncytin and PTENP1, but these are a small share of the thousands of shared elements. The shared disabling mutations in GULO, in particular, are hard to explain as design and are rarely addressed.

§7 Questions to ponder

  • If a feature shared by humans and apes turns out to be essential, is it still evidence of a shared accident?
  • “A designer would not reuse broken genes.” Is that a scientific claim or a theological one?
  • Which shared feature on this card would be hardest to explain by common design? Why?

§8 Sources

Supporting the mainstream claim
  1. Johnson WE, Coffin JM. “Constructing primate phylogenies from ancient retrovirus sequences.” PNAS 96:10254–10260 (1999).B
  2. Nishikimi M et al. “Cloning and chromosomal mapping of the human nonfunctional gene for L-gulono-γ-lactone oxidase, the enzyme for L-ascorbic acid biosynthesis missing in man.” Journal of Biological Chemistry 269:13685–13688 (1994).B
  3. Inai Y, Ohta Y, Nishikimi M. “The whole structure of the human nonfunctional L-gulono-γ-lactone oxidase gene—the gene responsible for scurvy—and the evolution of repetitive sequences thereon.” Journal of Nutritional Science and Vitaminology 49:315–319 (2003).B
  4. Schröder ARW et al. “HIV-1 integration in the human genome favors active genes and local hotspots.” Cell 110:521–529 (2002).B
  5. Mi S et al. “Syncytin is a captive retroviral envelope protein involved in human placental morphogenesis.” Nature 403:785–789 (2000).B
  6. Chuong EB, Elde NC, Feschotte C. “Regulatory evolution of innate immunity through co-option of endogenous retroviruses.” Science 351:1083–1087 (2016).B
  7. Poliseno L et al. “A coding-independent function of gene and pseudogene mRNAs regulates tumour biology.” Nature 465:1033–1038 (2010).B
  8. Hirotsune S et al. “An expressed pseudogene regulates the messenger-RNA stability of its homologous coding gene.” Nature 423:91–96 (2003).C
  9. Gray TA et al. “The putatively functional Mkrn1-p1 pseudogene is neither expressed nor imprinted, nor does it regulate its source gene in trans.” PNAS 103:12039–12044 (2006).B
Critical & alternative perspectives
  1. Wells J. The Myth of Junk DNA. Discovery Institute Press (2011), chs. 4–6.C

Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.

§9 Your notes