“Molecular clocks give reliable dates for when lineages diverged, independently of the fossil record.”
§1 The claim, as taught
Molecular clocks allow scientists to use the amount of genetic divergence between organisms to extrapolate backwards to estimate dates.University of California Museum of Paleontology. *Understanding Evolution*, “Evolution 101.”
§2 The strongest evidence offered
Molecular clocks are now built with sophisticated statistics. The question is what goes into them.
The original idea
Zuckerkandl and Pauling noticed that differences in proteins such as haemoglobin between species roughly tracked the time since divergence estimated from fossils, and proposed a molecular clock.Clocks set by fossils
A clock must be calibrated: the rate is obtained by assuming a divergence date, usually from fossils dated radiometrically. Modern methods use several calibrations and allow rates to vary, but the dates still depend on the calibrations and the model chosen.Rates that vary
Francisco Ayala showed that the rates of change in several proteins differ between lineages and over time, sometimes greatly, and called the precise clock a “mirage.” Graur and Martin criticised the habit of reporting precise dates from very uncertain calibrations.Faster in families than in trees
Mutation rates measured directly in families (pedigrees) for human mitochondrial DNA were up to about twenty times faster than rates inferred from species comparisons. Rate estimates depend on the time span over which they are measured.Clocks against rocks
Molecular clocks placed the origin of the animal phyla hundreds of millions of years before the Cambrian, long before any fossil animals. Later studies with other methods brought the dates closer to the fossils, but the gap has not closed.§3 The grade: two claims hiding in one
That sequences differ, and that differences accumulate, is one claim. That they keep time is another. Hover or tap a rung to see why it got its score. How the grading works →
DNA sequences accumulate differences at measurable rates
BStrongly supportedMolecular clocks give reliable divergence dates in millions of years
DExtrapolation§4 What it would take
To show that molecular clocks independently confirm the timescale, the following would be needed:
- An independent calibrationCalibrate a clock without using fossil or radiometric dates, and show that it gives the same deep-time dates.
- Rates that matchExplain why directly measured mutation rates are faster than inferred long-term rates, without assuming the long timescale.
- Agreement without adjustmentShow that clock dates and fossil dates agree before calibrations and rate models are tuned.
§5 Another reading of the same data
The molecular clock is an elegant idea, and in its first form it looked like an independent confirmation of the fossil timescale. Proteins that differ more between species seemed to belong to species that split longer ago. Over the following decades, the picture grew more complicated. Rates turned out to differ between genes, between lineages and over time. Calibrations became more numerous and more carefully argued, and the statistics far more sophisticated.
What did not change is the logic. A clock gives a ratio of differences to rate, and the rate comes from somewhere. In practice it comes from fossils whose ages come from radiometric dating. That makes the clock a way of interpolating the timescale, not of testing it. When clocks and fossils disagree, as they did by hundreds of millions of years over the origin of the animal phyla, the disagreement is resolved by adjusting one or the other.
Read through a recent-creation lens, the differences between species are not a stopwatch but a mix of original design differences and a few thousand years of mutation. That reading draws attention to the fast mutation rates measured directly in families, which on a short timescale would matter a great deal. The mainstream has an answer, that many of those mutations are lost before they become fixed differences, and the answer is reasonable. What the card shows is that the clock cannot settle the timescale on its own; it inherits its dates from the rocks.
§6 Reasoning check
The grade weighs the evidence. This check looks at the reasoning: the step from the evidence to the conclusion. The same tests are applied to both readings. How the reasoning check works →
- Possible
Clock dates are sometimes presented as independent evidence for deep time, though the clock is set using dates from Pillar 1. Multiple calibrations and rate models reduce but do not remove the dependence.
- Possible
When the strict clock failed, relaxed clocks allowed rates to vary freely. That is a reasonable refinement, but it reduces the clock's power to test the timescale.
- PossibleIn the evidence: Clocks set by fossils
When clock dates are offered as independent confirmation of the fossil and radiometric timescale, they confirm a timescale they were calibrated against.
- Possible
Faster pedigree rates fit a short timescale. They also fit the mainstream explanation that many new mutations are slightly harmful and are removed before they become fixed differences. The observation alone does not decide between them.
§7 Questions to ponder
- If a clock must be set using fossil dates, can it independently confirm those dates?
- Why might mutation rates measured in families be faster than those inferred from species differences?
- What would a recent-creation model predict about mutation rates and the differences between species?
§8 Sources
- Zuckerkandl E, Pauling L. “Evolutionary divergence and convergence in proteins.” In Bryson V, Vogel HJ (eds.), Evolving Genes and Proteins, pp. 97–166. Academic Press (1965).C
- Wray GA, Levinton JS, Shapiro LH. “Molecular evidence for deep Precambrian divergences among metazoan phyla.” Science 274:568–573 (1996).C
- Parsons TJ et al. “A high observed substitution rate in the human mitochondrial DNA control region.” Nature Genetics 15:363–368 (1997).B
- Ayala FJ. “Molecular clock mirages.” BioEssays 21:71–75 (1999).C
- Graur D, Martin W. “Reading the entrails of chickens: molecular timescales of evolution and the illusion of precision.” Trends in Genetics 20:80–86 (2004).C
- Ho SYW, Phillips MJ, Cooper A, Drummond AJ. “Time dependency of molecular rate estimates and systematic overestimation of recent divergence times.” Molecular Biology and Evolution 22:1561–1568 (2005).B
- dos Reis M, Donoghue PCJ, Yang Z. “Bayesian molecular clock dating of species divergences in the genomics era.” Nature Reviews Genetics 17:71–80 (2016).B
- Gibbons A. “Calibrating the mitochondrial clock.” Science 279:28–29 (1998).C
Source grades are provisional. In production each links to a full published evaluation that readers can challenge.