The Core Issues
Fourteen claim cards on the four questions the rest of the debate depends on. Each card takes about five minutes. Read them in order, or start with the issue that matters most to you.
1 hour · 14 stops
These are the cards that carry the most weight. If mutation and selection cannot produce new information, the fossil record does not show transitions, and the patterns of similarity can be explained another way, then the rest of the case is much weaker than it appears. If they can, the case is strong. Either way, these are the places to look.
Each card follows the same plan: the claim as taught, the strongest evidence offered for it, a grade, what it would take to raise the grade, a check of the reasoning on both sides, and an alternative reading. Your progress is ticked off below as you go, and saved on this device.
Issue 1 New information
Every other pillar assumes that mutation and selection can build new genes, proteins and systems. If they cannot, the rest of the theory has no engine. This is the place to start.
- Not yet visited№ 4.01Mutation & new informationThe central claim. Watch how the modest part (mutations change genes, and selection keeps some changes) is separated from the sweeping part (this produces new information).BD
- Not yet visited№ 4.03How rare are working proteins?How rare are working protein folds among all possible sequences? The answer decides whether random search could find them.BD
- Not yet visited№ 4.02Duplication & divergenceGene duplication is the textbook route to new genes. The card asks what the examples actually show.BD
- Not yet visited№ i.01Can nature make information?The lens on information: what kinds of cause are known to produce functional, specified information.BD
Issue 2 The fossil record
If the theory is true, the rocks should record the transitions. The fossil cards ask what they record instead.
- Not yet visited№ 2.02Cambrian explosionMost animal body plans appear abruptly in the Cambrian. Darwin saw this as a serious difficulty. Is the incomplete-record explanation adequate?BD
- Not yet visited№ 2.01Transitional seriesThe transitional series most often cited, such as whales and early tetrapods. Note what is observed and what is arranged.BD
- Not yet visited№ 7.02The origin of body plansThe origin of body plans brings the fossil and genetic questions together.BD
Issue 3 Common descent
Similarity is the main evidence for shared ancestry. These cards include the strongest mainstream arguments on the site. Read them with special care.
- Not yet visited№ 3.01HomologyHomology: shared structures across species. The pattern is real; what it shows is the question.AC
- Not yet visited№ 8.02Shared ERVs and pseudogenesShared viral insertions and broken genes at the same positions in humans and apes. This is one of the strongest arguments for common descent, and the card says so.AC
- Not yet visited№ 3.02The tree of lifeDo anatomy and molecules agree on one tree of life? Specialists report substantial conflict.BD
Issue 4 Human origins
The issue that touches people most directly. The four cards take the genetic and fossil evidence in turn.
- Not yet visited№ 9.01The 98% figureThe 98% figure: what was measured, and what was left out.AC
- Not yet visited№ 9.02Chromosome 2 fusionChromosome 2: the fusion evidence is good. The card asks what a fusion would show.BC
- Not yet visited№ 9.04The hominin fossilsThe hominin fossils, from Lucy to Homo naledi: a line of descent, or a bush with a divide?AC
- Not yet visited№ 9.03Adam, Eve and genetic diversityDoes human genetic diversity rule out a first couple? The answer depends on an assumption the models build in.BD
- Which of the four issues did you find the mainstream case strongest on? Which weakest?
- On which card did the creation reading face its hardest question?