The Deep Study
Four weekly units covering every pillar and lens. Each week has its claim cards, primary papers to read, and questions for discussion, and most weeks include an interactive tool or Darwin's own text. Plan on two or three hours a week.
4 weeks · 44 stops
The Deep Study covers every pillar and lens over four weeks. It is designed for a homeschool unit, a church study group or a reader working alone. Each week has three parts: the claim cards and tools, one or two primary papers, and questions for discussion.
The primary papers matter. The cards summarise and grade, but the papers are the evidence itself, written by the people who did the work. Where a paper is behind a paywall, its abstract is free, and most public and university libraries can provide the full text. Read the papers from both sides, and read each in its own terms before reading anyone's critique of it.
A note for group leaders: the questions have no answer key. The aim is to practise weighing evidence, not to reach a conclusion on schedule. If a group finishes the four weeks disagreeing, but able to say exactly where and why, the study has done its work.
Week 1 The rules and the clock
Start with how evidence is weighed, then with time, which every other argument depends on. By the end of the week you should be able to tell an observation from an inference, and say what radiometric dating measures directly.
- Not yet visitedMethodHow we gradeRead this first. The six steps, and the difference between observed, inferred and extrapolated, are used on every card.
- Not yet visitedMethodThe reasoning checkThe catalogue of reasoning errors the cards check for, on both sides.
- Not yet visited№ ii.01Is evolution falsifiable?Is evolution falsifiable? Popper's doubts, and his later change of mind.BC
- Not yet visited№ ii.02Is design unscientific?Is design unscientific by definition? The demarcation problem.BE
- Not yet visited№ 1.01The geologic columnThe geologic column: what the rock layers show, and how fast they can form.DC
- Not yet visited№ 1.02Radiometric datingRadiometric dating. The physics is strong, and the card says so. The question is the assumptions.AC
- Not yet visited№ 1.03Soft tissue in dinosaur boneSoft tissue in dinosaur bone: what was found, and how it is explained.BD
- Laudan L. “The demise of the demarcation problem.” In Cohen RS, Laudan L (eds.), Physics, Philosophy and Psychoanalysis, pp. 111–127. Reidel (1983). A leading philosopher of science on why no simple rule separates science from non-science.
- Schweitzer MH et al. “Soft-tissue vessels and cellular preservation in Tyrannosaurus rex.” Science 307:1952–1955 (2005). The original report. Read what the authors observed before reading anyone's interpretation.
- Pick one claim from this week. Which parts of it are observed, which inferred, and which extrapolated?
- What would count as evidence against a young earth? Against an old one? Are both sides willing to name it?
- Is it fair to rule an explanation out of science before looking at the evidence for it?
Week 2 The engine
Mutation and natural selection are the theory's engine. This week asks what they are observed to do, and whether the numbers allow them to do more.
- Not yet visited№ 5.01Darwin's finchesDarwin's finches: real, measured change. What kind of change?AD
- Not yet visited№ 5.03Antibiotic resistanceAntibiotic resistance: evolution happening now. The card asks how far it extrapolates.AD
- Not yet visited№ 5.02Peppered mothsThe peppered moth, and the controversy over the textbook photographs.BE
- Not yet visited№ 4.01Mutation & new informationMutation and new information: the central claim of the engine.BD
- Not yet visited№ 4.02Duplication & divergenceGene duplication and divergence.BD
- Not yet visited№ 4.03How rare are working proteins?How rare are working protein folds?BD
- Not yet visitedToolThe Probability SimulatorTry the numbers yourself: how long does it take to find a specific sequence by chance?
- Not yet visited№ 6.01The waiting-time problemThe waiting-time problem: is there time for coordinated mutations to arise?BD
- Not yet visited№ 6.02Harmful mutations & genetic entropyGenetic entropy: does selection remove harmful mutations as fast as they arise?BD
- Not yet visitedToolThe genetic entropy simulatorWatch harmful mutations accumulate in a model population, and change the settings.
- Not yet visited№ 6.03Drift and selectionDrift and selection together.BD
- Not yet visitedLibraryDarwin, Origin of Species, ch. IV: Natural SelectionRead Darwin's own argument for natural selection, with our section-by-section evaluation.
- Grant PR, Grant BR. “Unpredictable evolution in a 30-year study of Darwin's finches.” Science 296:707–711 (2002). Thirty years of careful field measurement. A model of observed evolution.
- Axe DD. “Estimating the prevalence of protein sequences adopting functional enzyme folds.” J. Mol. Biol. 341:1295–1315 (2004). The experiment behind the claim that working folds are extremely rare.
- Durrett R, Schmidt D. “Waiting for two mutations: with applications to regulatory sequence evolution and the limits of Darwinian evolution.” Genetics 180:1501–1509 (2008). A mainstream calculation of waiting times. Read it with Behe's reply and the authors' response.
- What is the difference between selection explaining which variants survive and explaining where the variants came from?
- If a change is observed in bacteria over decades, how far can it be projected? What would justify projecting it further?
- Darwin answered the charge that “natural selection” personifies nature. Does his answer work?
Week 3 The pattern
Fossils, anatomy and molecules are said to show one pattern of descent. This week examines the pattern, and includes the strongest mainstream arguments on the site.
- Not yet visited№ 2.01Transitional seriesTransitional series: whales, Tiktaalik and others.BD
- Not yet visited№ 2.02Cambrian explosionThe Cambrian explosion.BD
- Not yet visited№ 2.03StasisStasis: species that do not change for millions of years.BD
- Not yet visitedToolThe Fossil Record ExplorerLook at the specimens and the timeline for yourself.
- Not yet visited№ 3.01HomologyHomology.AC
- Not yet visitedToolThe Comparative Anatomy ViewerCompare the structures in 3D, with the mainstream reply alongside each argument.
- Not yet visited№ 3.02The tree of lifeThe tree of life.BD
- Not yet visited№ 3.03Embryos & developmentEmbryos, and Haeckel's drawings.CE
- Not yet visited№ 8.01Junk DNAJunk DNA: how much of the genome has a function?BC
- Not yet visited№ 8.02Shared ERVs and pseudogenesShared viral insertions and pseudogenes. Give this one your full attention: it is one of the strongest arguments for common descent.AC
- Not yet visited№ 8.03Molecular clocksMolecular clocks.BD
- Not yet visited№ 7.01Speciation and macroevolutionSpeciation: observed, and agreed by both sides. Is it macroevolution?AD
- Not yet visited№ 7.02The origin of body plansThe origin of body plans.BD
- Not yet visitedLibraryDarwin, Origin of Species, ch. X: On the Imperfection of the Geological RecordDarwin's own account of why the fossils did not show the transitions he expected.
- Erwin DH, Laflamme M, Tweedt SM, Sperling EA, Pisani D, Peterson KJ. “The Cambrian conundrum: early divergence and later ecological success in the early history of animals.” Science 334:1091–1097 (2011). Leading specialists on the Cambrian, in their own words.
- ENCODE Project Consortium. “An integrated encyclopedia of DNA elements in the human genome.” Nature 489:57–74 (2012). Read alongside Graur et al. (2013) in Genome Biology and Evolution, which disputes its definition of function.
- Which observation from this week would be hardest to explain without common descent? Say why.
- What would common design predict about shared similarities and shared mistakes in DNA? Is that prediction testable?
- Darwin expected the fossil record to be incomplete. When is an appeal to missing evidence reasonable, and when does it become a rescue?
Week 4 Origins
The last week turns to the beginnings: of life, of humans, and of the world as Genesis describes it. It ends with the scientists inside the field who say the standard theory needs rethinking.
- Not yet visited№ 10.01Miller–UreyMiller–Urey and the building blocks of life.AC
- Not yet visited№ 10.02The RNA worldThe RNA world.AD
- Not yet visited№ 10.03HomochiralityHomochirality: why life uses only one hand of its molecules.BD
- Not yet visited№ i.01Can nature make information?Can natural processes make functional information?BD
- Not yet visited№ 9.01The 98% figureThe 98% figure.AC
- Not yet visited№ 9.02Chromosome 2 fusionChromosome 2.BC
- Not yet visited№ 9.04The hominin fossilsThe hominin fossils.AC
- Not yet visited№ 9.03Adam, Eve and genetic diversityAdam, Eve and genetic diversity.BD
- Not yet visited№ iii.01Is Genesis history?Is Genesis history?BD
- Not yet visited№ iii.02Death before the FallDeath before the Fall.BD
- Not yet visited№ iv.01The Extended Synthesis debateThe Extended Synthesis debate.AD
- Miller SL. “A production of amino acids under possible primitive earth conditions.” Science 117:528–529 (1953). Two pages that launched a field. Note the gas mixture used.
- Laland K, Uller T, Feldman M, et al.; Wray GA, Hoekstra HE, Futuyma DJ, et al. “Does evolutionary theory need a rethink?” Nature 514:161–164 (2014). Both sides of the debate inside evolutionary biology, side by side.
- Venema DR, McKnight S. Adam and the Genome: Reading Scripture after Genetic Science. Brazos (2017). The strongest Christian case for a population origin of humans. Read it fairly, then read card 9.03.
- After four weeks, which pillar do you think is the strongest part of the mainstream case? Which is the weakest?
- Where does the creation reading face its hardest questions? How would you begin to answer them?
- How should Christians who disagree about these questions speak to one another, and about one another?